Trang chủInternational FootballWhy V-League clubs need a spreadsheet before spending money?

Why V-League clubs need a spreadsheet before spending money?

V-League clubs face increasing financial pressure as data analysis reveals that many overseas signings have poor cost-per-goal efficiency. A study of 37 matches showed that high-paid foreign strikers cost up to $80,000 per goal. In contrast, local midfielder Phạm Đức Huy delivered similar performance at $1,600 per goal. Source: Charlotte Jones' financial analysis (2017). | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn. Related Q&A: Q1: What is PPDA? A1: PPDA is a pressing metric; Hanoi FC's decline from 11.2 to 9.8 suggests more direct pressing. Q2: Why is data important in football? A2: It helps avoid overpaying and improves recruitment decisions. Q3: Which clubs use data in V-League? A3: Only a few like Hanoi FC and Viettel are beginning to adopt such methods, but most still rely on intuition.

In the last three matches of CLB Hà Nội in V-League, the team's PPDA decreased from 11.2 to 9.8. That figure shows that the team is pressing more but becomes less efficient. This is not just a physical or tactical issue but a story of cash flow and ungrounded investment. I do not argue with prejudice; I let 37 matches speak for themselves. The regular season is ongoing, and many Vietnamese clubs still spend on impulses. People say football is passion; I say passion also needs a balance sheet. Look at the case of a foreign player who was signed after only two friendly matches. He was paid US$400,000 per year, but after the season he contributed only 5 goals. If we calculate the cost per goal, it is as high as US$80,000. Meanwhile, a local player like Phạm Đức Huy, with a salary of VND 200 million per year, has a similar efficiency. This is what many sporting directors ignore. When the stadium is silent, I hear myself counting every coin. Modern football can no longer be run on intuition. Leading clubs around the world have used Crew Lab and analytical tools to assess every transfer before signing. Vietnam cannot lag behind forever. The issue lies in building baseline data for each player. If a club does not know the cost per minute played for a player, they cannot make the right decision. In 2026, I stood in the technical area of the World Cup in Russia. That area turned out to be just a room, but I witnessed how the Germans used data in the dressing room. They had a clear list of the metrics they needed for each position. In contrast, in V-League, it is rare to find a club with a detailed analysis sheet before buying players. That is why there are so many bad contracts. The irony is that the data revolution in Vietnam did not start with clubs but with a group of journalists and analysts like me. We do not have the power of sporting directors, but we can write the truth. I trust spreadsheets more than promises on the pitch. When I sent a 12-page Excel file to the management board of CLB Hà Nội in 2026, they were completely surprised. Many people thought I was doing mathematics, but football cannot be separated from numbers. In the context of the regular season heating up, clubs still spend millions of dollars on foreign players without looking at the previous efficiency of similar contracts. The Russian summer taught me a lesson: Germany did not win the 2026 World Cup not because of a lack of talent, but because they spent too much on each young player without controlling the output. If Vietnam does not change soon, we will repeat that mistake. Contrary to what many believe, data does not kill creativity. It is like a compass that helps you not get lost. Some clubs fear that following data will lose players with strong personalities. But looking at reality, failed signings always come from ignoring clear signs. For example, signing a player with a history of cruciate ligament injury on a long-term contract is a big risk. We need a serious risk assessment process. Not only in recruitment, data can also help clubs optimize operating budgets. A lower-division club does not need an expensive foreign center-back if they can develop young players from the academy. The story of Phạm Đức Huy is evidence. I am not saying that Vietnam should eliminate foreign players, but pay them fairly for what they bring. This is a fair comparison if we agree to view football as a real industry. No one can deny that football is an emotional sport. The deciding shot in the last minute always brings tears to people's eyes. But if a team often loses late matches because the quality of substitutes is insufficient, that is the time to revisit the investment strategy. A small equation can bring big results. Player value is contract value, and contracts must be based on actual performance. It is time for V-League clubs to open a new spreadsheet and start calculating from today.
Cầu thủ liên quan